Refutation of Bin Bayyah/Hamza Yusuf
Upon additional examination and studies of this account of container Bayyah, i ran across that his or her assertions tends to be erroneous and deceiving in several ways:
The scholars decided not to vary inside matter after all because there had been ijmaa€? on prohibition of congratulating non-Muslims on their holiday breaks. This opinion am said by Ibn al-Qayyim as he believed, a€?Congratulating the non-Muslims for their traditions that belong merely to these people was haram by consensus (associated with scholars).a€? 16 for that reason, this ijmaa€? that was well established is not to be damaged under any scenario as well as well-known among the students of fiqh and usul. And homeowners who report that ijmaa€? was not well-known inside matter, next the burden of evidence can be found upon these to create their unique report. Neither trash Bayyah nor one of the people latest scholars offering fatwa of permissibility indicate whatever would nullify the declaration of ijmaa€? by Ibn al-Qayyim.
In actuality, there are only two views in madhhab of Imam Ahmad, haram and makruh, and not three as Bin Bayyah stated. Additionally, the setting of the two thoughts through the madhhab was not regarding congratulating kuffar on their festivals, but instead it had been in the context of congratulating these people on non-religious pleased affair, as Ibn al-Qayyim reference. Also, al-Mardawi states, a€?The next view is it’s not restricted but disliked as documented for the guides of Ria€?ayah and al-Hawiyayn inside the section of janaa€™iz.a€? 17 Al-Mardawi proceeds to quote the exemplory case of the Prophet i·? checking out unwell Jewish kid to ensure that he may take Islam. Thus, it can be mentioned without a doubt the situation of makruh had not been when it comes to congratulating non-Muslims to their fests and holidays although with reference to seeing all of them when are unwell or normal hello on non-religious opportunities.
With regard to Ibn Taymiyyah seeking the thoughts of permissibility in congratulating non-Muslims on their celebrations, this is exactly inaccurate together with erroneous as al-Mardawi shows the framework in which Ibn Taymiyyah decided to go with this a€?permissibilitya€™ by stating: a€?It (visiting the company’s ill) is actually permissible for an assured maslahah (as a whole close) for usa sex guide instance the believe that they’ll acknowledge Islam. This thoughts got preferred by Ibn Taymiyyah.a€? 18 also, how should it is feasible for Ibn Taymiyyah to search for the viewpoint of permissibility when he unmistakably and unquestionably was from the advice that congratulating and taking part within these festivals, despite they getting religious or non-religious, is wholly prohibited? 19 Furthermore, for trash Bayyah to convey that Ibn Taymiyyaha€™s a€?confirmeda€™ advice usually of permissibility is incredibly misleading, because his own a€?confirmeda€™ advice is exactly what are relayed by him or her as part of his popular work of art, Iqtidaa€™ al-Sirat al-Mustaqim fi Mukhalafati Ashab al-Jaa??im, that is definitely completely and entirely designed for no congratulating and partaking in the festivals of non-Muslims.
Suhaib Webb
The type of that also let congratulating non-Muslims for their celebrations is definitely Suhaib Webb. On December 26, 2012 they posted on his own particular facebook or myspace webpage what things can be looked at a justification for greeting non-Muslims on holiday and unique Yeara€™s. This individual states:
The American Fatwa Council; constructed from 20 associated with worlda€™s ultimate Muslim Jurists, reported that it is allowable to welcome folks on nowadays (exchange presents also) given that it won’t require approving any creedal differences when considering north america, or open wicked (ingesting and many others). Put differently, a fairly easy happier holiday season is not at all a sin or likely need see your face away Islam. Its described with real stores that Ali (ra) famed the Persian new-year, actually taking in frozen dessert with Imam Abu Hanifaa€™s family member. Some of the fatwa quoted by sincere folks are grounded on an age of kingdom and war (the crusades) or a social fact that doesn’t in shape mine when you look at the West. First and foremost, people should inquire those who incorporate words like a€?harama€? a€?kufura€? a€?Halala€? and a€?encourageda€? about their spiritual tuition. Crying as well as taken emotionalism don’t equal instruction and fund. Allah understands better. (Webb, 2012).
